Recruiting young people tools
Use our range of practical tools to help you recruit, manage and support young people
The CIPD welcomes Milburn’s proposals to support youth recruitment, but warns that government employment policies must not undermine efforts to create more opportunities.
The CIPD has backed the Milburn Review’s diagnosis of youth unemployment, but says the new deal it proposes only works if government delivers its side. Chief executive Neil Carberry says employers are ready to step up. The CIPD wants government to tackle the costs and rules that hold back hiring across the UK.
The review gets something important right. Building young people’s skills isn’t enough on its own. Employers also need the confidence and the incentives to take a chance on young people. Recruiting on potential helps, but employers can’t close the gap alone.
"Employers will be ready to step up – but a deal implies action by both sides. Government cannot simply outsource the risk of success onto employers."
A handful of well-targeted, small-scale schemes won’t be enough for government to do its part. Sustainable jobs depend on successful employers who can afford to take someone on.
That means a proper workforce strategy. It should link decisions on skills, innovation, business support and employment regulation, so they all pull in the same direction. It should also tackle the barriers to youth employment that government policy can create.
We welcome the review’s overdue recognition that rising employer National Insurance costs are a huge barrier to hiring. We’ve consistently called for government to reverse the cut to the threshold from £9,100 to £5,000. Raising the threshold for 21 to 24-year-olds is the right step, as the cut was the main challenge for employers.
The review starts with a scheme for key sectors that saves up to £750 a year for each employee. It’s complex, but it could work if it’s aimed at those sectors at scale. We think a simpler option would do more. Restoring the wider threshold towards its previous £9,100 level would be simpler and fairer to all employers, and do more to create jobs.
Our research shows how much this matters. In our Summer 2025 Labour Market Outlook report, 84% of employers said their costs had risen because of higher employer National Insurance contributions. A third (32%) said costs had risen to a large extent. Employers named it their biggest cost pressure over the previous 12 months.
The effect reaches employers who hire young people too. Under-21s are exempt from employer National Insurance, yet 37% of employers who hire them said the changes had still raised their costs to a large extent. Among employers who don’t hire under-21s, 23% said the same.
The review proposes a youth test. It would make government check how its policies affect young people’s chances of getting into work. We see that as a positive step. But employers will be sceptical about whether it will bind government thinking.
The quickest way to prove it is to use it now. Government should put Employment Rights Act 2025 measures that aren’t yet in force through the test straight away, including the guaranteed hours reforms.
Zero-hours contracts matter here. They’re a crucial entry point to work for young people, and half a million depend on them to earn, learn new skills and balance work with study. Our Winter 2025/26 Labour Market Outlook report shows how employers expect the ERA 2025 to affect them. 74% expected it to increase their employment costs. More than a third (37%) planned to hire fewer permanent staff because of at least one of its key reforms.
"It’s hugely positive to see so much of what we’ve called for in recent years in Milburn’s recommendations."
We’ve long called for a national pre-apprenticeship programme, so the new pathway is welcome. It will work best with real employer involvement, clear routes into apprenticeships and enough places to move on to.
We also back reinvesting Growth and Skills Levy receipts in the apprenticeship and skills system. The £2,500 wage incentive for employers of all sizes is welcome too. Alongside fully funded training, it will help meet the cost of recruiting and supporting young apprentices. Our own Apprenticeship Guarantee proposal includes a £5,200 wage grant for employers who take on 16 to 18-year-olds.
The deal also tilts the apprenticeship system towards young people. The review asks employers to contribute an extra 25% towards apprenticeships for older workers, which frees up more funding for the young. We agree we need to revitalise apprenticeships for young people, ideally with a new Apprenticeship Guarantee. But there’s a risk that some employers cut back on learning for older workers.
Government should consult employers before it makes this change. It should also assess the impact on overall training investment, skills shortages and youth recruitment. Employers will want to be sure that, if they take on this extra cost, government delivers its side of the deal. That includes action on the cost of hiring and a better-performing wider skills system.
Employers are ready to step up. If government matches that with action on hiring costs, skills and regulation, the deal could open up many more opportunities for young people.
Use our range of practical tools to help you recruit, manage and support young people
Explore our wide range of best practice recruitment resources and gain the knowledge to benefit your organisation.