Effective performance management lies at the heart of HR, but the body of knowledge on this crucial topic is far from settled. It is an area in which common practice is in flux, with a number of key established approaches being challenged over recent years. In our review of the best available evidence on performance management, 'Could do Better?', we set out the scientific research on what works and what doesn’t in goal setting and performance appraisal.

However, one area that has been lacking in high quality research concerns the effectiveness of a strengths-based approach in performance management – our review uncovered just one study testing the impact in a rigorous way, which was conducted in a Canadian private sector organisation.

Our organisational field trial helps address this gap, showing what difference strengths-based performance conversations can make in the UK public sector. Working with three UK government employers, we conducted a group randomised trial of an intervention to embed a strengths-based approach to performance management.

Our research shows that interventions promoting strengths-based performance conversations can have a measurable impact on what conversations take place between managers and their staff, and on the usefulness of one-to-one meetings for employees’ learning and development and performance. Specifically, we show that a one-off half-day training workshop for line managers has an impact on employee performance; and an impact on employee learning and development seems to require a more extensive, holistic intervention that includes further training, communication and practical guidance and a change in policy on performance management.

This report also provides an example of how robust, contextualised and useful research can be conducted into people management practices. HR and people development needs more research of this nature if it is to become a truly evidence based profession.

Download the Exec summary, Report, and Appendix 1: methodology below:

Video: Changing trends in performance management

In this video, Jonny Gifford, Senior Adviser for Organisational Behaviour at the CIPD, explores the changing trends in performance management over recent years.

More on this topic

Bitesize research
Improving feedback to improve performance

This research outlines recommendations for making feedback discussions more constructive

For Members
Performance reviews

Understand the basics of performance reviews and how to ensure the process adds value to the organisation

For Members
Performance management: an introduction

Understand how to build an effective approach to performance management, including the tools that can support it

Competence and competency frameworks

Examines the history, principles and current practice around competence and competency frameworks

For Members

More reports

CIPD Good Work Index: Northern Ireland

A Northern Ireland summary of the CIPD Good Work Index 2024 survey report

CIPD Good Work Index: Wales

A Wales summary of the CIPD Good Work Index 2024 survey report

Working Lives Scotland

Dedicated analysis of job quality and its impact on working lives in Scotland

CIPD Good Work Index: North of England

A North of England summary of the CIPD Good Work Index 2024 survey report

See all reports