The culture of giving feedback in the workplace as part of performance management is generally viewed as a positive method for improving performance – and there is a lot of research which backs this up. But feedback can also be detrimental to performance if not done in the right way.

People professionals and leaders in organisations need to have an understanding of what makes feedback effective or destructive, and ensure constructive feedback becomes part of performance management practices.

This evidence review looks at the key lessons in making feedback effective, and explores how people professionals can implement this through policies and by building people’s capabilities.

See the practice summary for the main insights and practical recommendations for action. 

See the scientific summary for our methodology and technical information on the research and study references.

Member tool: CIPD Buddy BETA
Experiment with AI to find answers on this topic with our prototype. Login to explore CIPD Buddy

Members access only

Unlock exclusive, tailored content and resources, just for members.

Sign in to access

Not a member yet? Find out how you can become a member today!

More on this topic

Podcast
Driving performance with people analytics

People metrics are not often black and white, but how can you better utilise people data to paint a truer picture of employee performance?

Bitesize research
Improving feedback to improve performance

This research outlines recommendations for making feedback discussions more constructive

For Members
Factsheet
Performance reviews

Understand the basics of performance reviews and how to ensure the process adds value to the organisation

For Members
Factsheet
Performance management: an introduction

Understand how to build an effective approach to performance management, including the tools that can support it

Latest evidence reviews

Evidence review
Trust and psychological safety: An evidence review

Find out what the evidence says about building trust and psychological safety

For Members
Evidence review
Effective people managers: Evidence review

Research exploring how to develop people managers who drive organisational success

For Members
Evidence review
High-performing teams: An evidence review

Explore the latest research on how to create a positive environment to build and nurture effective teams

Evidence review
Productive meetings: An evidence review

This evidence review summarises the latest research on the effective management of meetings and offers recommendations to get the most out of them

For Members
All evidence reviews