When an academic assignment asks you to “critically review” or include a “critical analysis” of the work of other people, it generally means that you’ll need to “think critically”. This means analysing and assessing the work in terms of what the author was trying to achieve, the approach they took, how they conducted the research, and whether the outcomes were valid and acceptable. 

A critical review evaluates the strengths and weaknesses of an item’s ideas and content. It provides description, analysis and interpretation that assess the item’s value. It’s an exercise that can be carried out on many different types of writing, but is most often carried out on a report, a book or a journal article. 

Thousands of publications relevant to HR appear every year, via established journals, websites, management consultancy reports and universities all over the world. With so much information becoming available, many of which offer new ideas, new HR theories and approaches, it’s important that HR practitioners can evaluate whether what they read is valid, sound and unbiased. We can’t take everything we read at face value, and it’s an important skill, and a very important activity to conduct, if you’re going to base corporate change and your proposals to management on information from published sources. 

Selecting an item to review

The critical review process

Writing the critical review

Useful contacts and books

 

View our other study guides

Guides

How to set out references

Our guide to helping you compile bibliographies based on the Harvard system.

Guides

How to Study Effectively

There are a number of key considerations when developing an approach to studying to suit you. These study tips will help ensure you study effectively.

Guides

How to write a persuasive business report

Practical advice on the report-writing process, with key steps to improve the quality of business reports

Guides

How to Write an academic essay

An academic essay is a formal piece of writing which presents an argument to the reader. Learn how to write persuasive and robust academic essays.

More on this topic

Career hub

Interactive career tools, including career assessments, personal development planner, elevator pitch builder, and interview simulator.

Guides
How to Write an academic essay

An academic essay is a formal piece of writing which presents an argument to the reader. Learn how to write persuasive and robust academic essays.

Webinars
Jobs search webinars 2022

Supporting CIPD members in successful job search

Webinars
CIPD qualifications webinar: Take your career to the next level

Listen to our webinar to hear how our new qualifications could give you the skills and knowledge you need to excel in the people profession.

Latest guides

Guides
People manager guide: Supporting employee resilience

Practical guidance on helping employees adapt and thrive when faced with workplace stress

For Members
Guides
Resilience: Guide for people professionals to support employees

Advice and tips on how HR professionals can support organisational and individual resilience

For Members
Guides
Internships that work: Guide for employers

Guidance for employers on starting or improving an internship programme, including a checklist and model agreement

For Members
Guides
Planning and managing flexible working

Maximise the benefits of flexible working, incorporating flexibility into people plans, strategy, and EVP

All guides