Member tool: CIPD Buddy BETA
Experiment with AI to find answers on this topic with our prototype. Login to explore CIPD Buddy

Essential points

  • The rights someone has at work are dependent on whether they are an employee, a worker or self-employed.
  • Employment status is not clearly defined in legislation. There are definitions for tax purposes and certain legal tests, however these are different to how these employment statuses are defined and assessed  for employment law purposes.
  • Being clear about an individual’s employment law status is important because the different category and nature of the engagement with an organization determines their rights and the organisation’s obligations, including tax treatment.
  • The growth in the gig economy has given rise to increasing numbers of  claims by ‘workers’  and the courts have grappled with determining whether an individual is a worker rather than an employee or self-employed and made clear that certain minimum rights apply to workers, such as holiday entitlement.  This has occurred where some businesses have sought to structure their arrangements people working for them as self-employed contract; however, the individuals consider  their employment status is that of a worker. This issue has been (and continues) to be  tested extensively in court and examples of these cases are provided on this page.

There are two major changes proposed relating to employment status in the government's plan to Make Work Pay:

  • The first is new rights for workers on zero hours contracts to be offered guaranteed hours which is set out in more detail in the Employment Rights Bill 2024.
  • The second is a longer-term ambition to create a single status of 'worker'; this would replace the three employment status categories. The proposal will extend employment rights and allow two categories of engagement, worker and self-employed.

Keep up to date with the these proposals in the plan to Make Work Pay tracker.

This page outlines the current legislation on employment status, the tests applied by tribunals and courts, and example case law. Current law should be followed until any changes come into force. We will update this page once any changes are enforced.

To continue reading, log in or become a member

Affiliate membership offers instant access to CIPD resources without the need for assessments or study, or explore your options to become a professional member of the CIPD to demonstrate your commitment to the world of work.

  • Access to exclusive, up-to-date resources
  • Become part of a community to learn, debate and connect with other people professionals
  • Free access to a series of CIPD learning courses and a discount on the rest of our catalogue

Disclaimer 

Please note: While every care has been taken in compiling this content, CIPD cannot be held responsible for any errors or omissions. These notes are not intended to be a substitute for specific legal advice. 

Employment
law advice

Want more employment law advice? Members can phone the CIPD legal helpline or take out a discounted subscription to HR-inform for additional resources.

Callout Image
  • Data

    Data hub

    Explore the evidence behind workforce trends

  • Factsheet

    Employment status

    Understand how being defined in UK law as an employee, a worker or self-employed affects employment rights and employers’ legal responsibilities

    For Members
  • Employment law
  • Employment law

    Annual leave: UK employment law

    The CIPD's dedicated legal resource on holiday entitlement for all types of worker. This page includes guidance leave allowances and pay.

    For Members
  • Employment law

    Tracking UK law changes under the ERB

    Keep up to date with what will change under the Employment Rights Bill, the Equality (Race and Disability) Bill and the plan to Make Work Pay

    For Members